7 Relationships between sources of power, according to different theoretical
systems
- Mann argues that power exists in the context of power networks,
within which the different sources of power are intertwined in flexible and
variable ways. Power networks are the frameworks of societies,
which are networks of social interaction characterised by power
relationships.
- Other social scientists see societies in terms of more definite systems
of power relations, i.e. more closed and hierarchically organized structures. Thus they propose reductive concepts of
power in which one source is seen as determinant, with explanatory
priority:
- many IR Realists see states as units in an international system
of states, - priority of political and military power over economic and ideological/cultural power.
- Marxists see an opposite hierarchy of 'levels' in social formations,
especially the capitalist system - economic power has priority over political and military power.
- Some post-modern and gender theorists stress the priority of cultural
relations and forms of power
Spheres in society
- economy/mode of
production, state (politics+military), culture/ideology, characterised by
different kinds of power
- international and domestic
spheres as characterised by different kinds of power relations.
division of labour in the social sciences:
- Sociology, politics, etc. have seen society/politics in terms of domestic
realities
- IR has analysed interstate relations separately from domestic politics.
- However with globalization, these divisions have started to break down.
interests and values
Analyses of
international relations in terms of power
tends to emphasise the role of interests. If
actors tend to pursue power, of whatever kind, then are their values
anything more than rationalisations of their interests?
(question for next time)